Broussard Services

Should You DIY or Hire a Professional Plumber? A Comprehensive Comparison

When a pipe bursts in the middle of the night, or when a clogged sink becomes your worst enemy, you face two choices: tackle the problem yourself or call a professional plumber. While doing things by yourself may offer the satisfaction of hands-on work and potentially save you some pennies, hiring a professional plumber could mean expert solutions that stand the test of time. In this blog post, we dig into the nitty-gritty of the DIY vs professional plumbing war, helping you better understand where to tie your allegiances when your home’s waterworks go haywire. Dive into our comprehensive comparison and make an informed decision the next time your bathroom decides to challenge you!

DIY vs Professional Plumber

Benefits and Drawbacks of DIY Plumbing

When faced with a plumbing issue, you might find yourself contemplating whether to roll up your sleeves and tackle it yourself or hire a professional plumber. Let's explore the benefits and drawbacks of DIY plumbing.

One of the significant advantages of DIY plumbing is the potential cost savings. By taking on the task yourself, you can avoid paying for labor costs, which can add up quickly when dealing with complex plumbing projects. Additionally, purchasing materials directly and researching for the best deals can help keep expenses in check. This can be particularly enticing for those on a tight budget or looking to save money.

However, it's essential to acknowledge the drawbacks as well. Poor execution is a common risk when attempting DIY plumbing tasks. Without proper knowledge and experience, there's a chance you may not complete the job correctly or even exacerbate the problem further. Plumbing systems are intricate, and a small mistake can lead to more significant issues down the line.

Another drawback is underestimating the complexity of the task at hand. While some plumbing issues may appear simple on the surface, they could involve underlying complexities that require specialized tools or expertise to address effectively. Without these resources or knowledge, you might find yourself in over your head.

It's crucial to assess your comfort level and understanding of plumbing before embarking on a DIY project. Some tasks may be suitable for those with basic skills and knowledge, such as fixing leaky faucets or unclogging slow-moving drains. However, more complex plumbing tasks like installing new plumbing, replacing leaking pipes, or water softener installations are better left to professionals who possess extensive experience and specialized tools.

Now that we've explored the potential benefits and drawbacks of DIY plumbing let's delve deeper into two specific aspects: personal satisfaction and cost savings.

  • In 2022, HomeAdvisor reported that the average cost to hire a plumber for a common job like repairing a leaky faucet fell between $175 and $450, while the DIY cost for parts was generally less than $50.
  • According to Statista, approximately 64% of homeowners in the United States undertook some form of DIY home improvement project in 2020, including plumbing tasks.
  • A survey by ImproveNet in 2019 found that nearly two-thirds (63%) of homeowners who attempted DIY household repairs, including plumbing tasks, regretted not calling a professional to handle the job from the start.

Personal Satisfaction and Cost Saving

Getting your hands dirty and successfully resolving a plumbing issue on your own can be deeply satisfying. It allows you to take ownership of the problem and experience a sense of accomplishment. Imagine the pride you would feel when you fix a leaky faucet or install a new showerhead, knowing that you did it yourself.

Moreover, DIY plumbing can offer substantial cost savings. As mentioned earlier, by cutting out labor costs, you can potentially save a significant amount of money. Additionally, researching for the best deals on materials and tools further contributes to cost-effectiveness. These savings can be particularly attractive when faced with a tight budget or a simple plumbing issue that doesn't require extensive expertise.

However, it's important to recognize that personal satisfaction and cost savings must be weighed against potential risks. While there is joy in successfully completing a DIY plumbing project, there is also the possibility of errors or inadequate fixes. In such cases, additional expenses may arise from hiring a professional to rectify the mistakes or address any underlying issues.

Furthermore, certain plumbing tasks require expertise and specialized tools to ensure proper installation and long-term durability. By opting for professional services, you gain access to their knowledge, experience, and familiarity with plumbing codes and regulations. This level of expertise can prevent future problems that could end up being more costly in the long run.

Risk of Poor Execution and Underestimation of Complexity

When it comes to tackling plumbing projects, there is a significant risk associated with poor execution and underestimating the complexity of the task at hand. DIY enthusiasts may find themselves in a bind when faced with unexpected issues that arise during the project. Plumbing systems can be intricate, and what may appear as a simple fix on the surface can quickly escalate into a more complex problem. Without the necessary experience or expertise, attempting these repairs on your own could potentially worsen the situation, leading to costly repairs down the line.

For instance, let's say you decide to replace a leaking pipe under your sink without professional assistance. As you begin working, you realize that the entire pipeline needs replacement due to corrosion. Without proper knowledge and tools, you may end up causing further damage or incomplete repairs, resulting in continuous leaks and potential water damage to your property.

Underestimating complexity can also lead to frustration and disappointment if you aren't prepared for unforeseen challenges. It's important to consider the extent of your plumbing knowledge and skillset before deciding whether to take on a project yourself.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Professional Plumbers

Now that we've discussed the risks involved in DIY plumbing, let's explore the advantages and disadvantages of hiring professional plumbers for your plumbing needs.


Professional plumbers bring extensive knowledge, training, and experience to each job they undertake. They have undergone rigorous training programs and typically hold proper licensing, ensuring their competency in handling various plumbing tasks. Their expertise allows them to efficiently diagnose problems and recommend appropriate solutions.

Another advantage lies in their familiarity with plumbing codes and regulations. They are well-versed in local building codes and can ensure that all work performed complies with these standards. This is particularly crucial when tackling larger projects such as installing new fixtures like toilets, tubs, showers, or relocating existing plumbing.

Hiring a professional plumber also allows for the detection of underlying issues that may not be immediately evident. Their trained eyes can spot potential problems during the course of their work, preventing future complications and potentially saving you from costly repairs in the long run.

Think of professional plumbers as the doctors of your plumbing system. They have the expertise to diagnose and treat any issues that arise, ensuring the health and functionality of your plumbing infrastructure.


One main disadvantage of hiring a professional plumber is the cost associated with their services. While this cost may vary depending on the job scope, complexity, and location, it's important to budget accordingly as labor charges can add up quickly. Additionally, some professional plumbers may charge higher prices for supplies compared to what you could find at a local hardware store.

There is also the possibility of scheduling conflicts or delays when hiring professionals due to their availability. Plumbing emergencies often require immediate attention, and waiting for an available appointment slot might not always be feasible.

Ultimately, weighing the advantages and disadvantages will help you determine whether hiring a professional plumber is the right choice for your specific plumbing needs, taking into consideration factors such as budget, time constraints, and the level of DIY skills you possess.

Expertise and Compliance with Regulations

When it comes to plumbing, expertise and compliance with regulations are essential factors to consider. A professional plumber brings years of experience, extensive knowledge, and familiarity with plumbing codes and regulations. They have undergone proper training and possess the necessary licenses to ensure the work is done correctly and in line with safety guidelines. This expertise ensures that not only is your plumbing issue addressed effectively, but it also mitigates the risk of any potential problems down the line due to improper installation or repairs.

For instance, if you were considering installing a new fixture such as a toilet or shower in your home, hiring a professional plumber would ensure that it is properly connected to your plumbing system, preventing leaks and potential damage.

Moreover, professional plumbers have the ability to detect other underlying issues that may not be apparent to an untrained eye. By addressing these problems early on, you can potentially save yourself from more extensive repairs and expenses in the future.

Higher Initial Costs

One of the key considerations when deciding between DIY plumbing and hiring a professional plumber is the difference in initial costs. DIY plumbing projects often come with lower upfront expenses as you only need to purchase materials and supplies for the job. This can be especially attractive for smaller tasks like fixing leaky faucets or installing new shower heads.

However, it's important to note that while DIY may seem cost-effective initially, there are potential risks involved. If a DIY project goes awry or if mistakes are made during the process, you could end up spending more money to fix the problems caused by your own lack of expertise. Additionally, purchasing subpar materials or tools could result in rework or premature replacements.

On the other hand, hiring a professional plumber may come with higher labor costs and potentially higher costs for supplies since they typically have access to higher-quality materials. However, their expertise can help avoid costly mistakes and ensure that the job is done right the first time.

Consider this scenario: You decide to tackle a plumbing project yourself but end up causing a pipe to burst, leading to significant water damage in your home. The costs associated with repairing the damage and fixing the original issue could far outweigh what you would have paid for professional assistance in the first place.

As we can see, cost is a crucial factor to consider when making the decision between DIY plumbing and hiring a professional plumber. Let's explore this further with a thorough cost-benefit analysis.

Cost-Benefit Analysis Between DIY and Hiring a Plumber

When faced with plumbing issues, homeowners often find themselves torn between DIY fixes and hiring a professional plumber. While attempting to tackle the problem on your own may save money upfront, it's essential to weigh the potential costs and benefits involved.

On one hand, DIY plumbing repairs can be an empowering experience, providing a sense of accomplishment and potentially saving you money. For minor issues like unclogging a drain or replacing a faucet washer, a DIY approach can be both cost-effective and feasible. It allows you to have control over the repair process and eliminates potential scheduling conflicts with plumbers.

However, it is crucial to consider the downside as well. Plumbing systems are intricate and complex, meaning that even seemingly simple tasks can quickly turn into major problems if not handled correctly. Mistakes made during DIY repairs can lead to more significant damage, costing you additional time, effort, and money to fix in the long run.

Moreover, certain plumbing repairs require specialized skills, tools, and knowledge that only professional plumbers possess. Attempting to tackle these tasks without sufficient expertise could result in accidents or further damage to your plumbing system.

Ultimately, the decision to DIY or hire a professional plumber comes down to your level of confidence and familiarity with plumbing repairs, as well as the complexity of the issue at hand. While some homeowners may feel capable of undertaking small repairs themselves, larger or more intricate problems may necessitate professional intervention for optimal results.

Now that we've discussed the cost-benefit analysis between DIY and hiring a plumber let's explore how one can assess the complexity of common plumbing tasks to make an informed decision.

Assessing the Complexity of Common Plumbing Tasks

Before you decide whether to tackle a plumbing task on your own or hire a professional plumber, it's crucial to assess the complexity of the job. This evaluation can help you gauge your own capabilities and determine whether professional expertise is necessary.

Consider factors such as the type of plumbing repair required, the tools and materials involved, and your prior experience with similar tasks. Simple repairs like replacing a washer or unclogging a drain may be within reach for some homeowners. On the other hand, more complex tasks like rerouting pipes or repairing a water heater may require specialized knowledge and equipment.

It's also important to consider the potential consequences of making mistakes during the repair process. Certain tasks, such as working with gas lines or handling sewage systems, pose significant health and safety risks if not handled properly. If you're unsure about the complexity of a particular task or lack confidence in your abilities, it may be best to consult a professional plumber.

Remember, plumbing repairs gone wrong can lead to extensive damage to your home and potentially cost more in the long run. Assessing the complexity of the task can help you make an informed decision that ensures both your safety and the proper functioning of your plumbing system.

If you're considering getting expert help, don't hesitate to call Broussard Services. Our team of professionals is always ready to help solve any plumbing problem you may have. We'll troubleshoot the issue and get your system up and running again in no time. Please don't hesitate to get in touch with us by calling either 228-271-3205 or 615-988-6030.

Broussard Services

Mississippi Location
14405 Cullen St
Biloxi, MS 39532

Tennessee  Location
117 Lemuel Rd.
Nashville, TN 37207
Ph: 615-988-6030


Biloxi Office:

Nashville Office:



Sunday  Closed
Mon - Fri   - 
Saturday  Closed
©2022 Broussard Services. All rights reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy